
Rating:
Buy it from Insound
Download it from Emusic
Digg this article
Add to del.icio.usI put the disc in the player and began to leaf through the kit. Sure, I was just looking for my name somewhere in the clippings, and I suppose it would have helped to have previously written about them before. But that's fine because I can sit there and mock my fellow writers by playing the "Sounds Like..." drinking game or trying to find the biggest cliché of them all. The winner was a tie between Mr. Showbiz's Grant Alden, who referred to Perfect as "...less ebullient than its predecessor, and has a wry durability about itself, yielding polished gems..." and the usual hands- down winner, Will Hermes of the Village Voice, who actually managed to string together the words, "As far as rock goes, the stay- at- home types seem peculiarly American these days, a gesture from a post- grunge culture weary and dubious of being the biggest, loudest, and most important, just as current Britpop might be read, in part, as postcolonialist white British weary of apologizing for its history and looking to feel good about itself again" and call it a coherent sentence.
The one thread that held every single review and article together was how different Perfect was from the band's previous release, 1993's There's Nothing Wrong With Love. Love was built on short, sharp, and snappy pop songs, but Perfect was-- as everybody went on to note-- "epic." Indeed, the 1996 release had few tunes under six minutes and wove dense guitars, emotional debris, and schizophrenic song structures into something gorgeous and fascinating. As avid readers of music publications will note as the reviews trickle in, Keep It Like a Secret will be heralded for retreating back to the pop songs of Love while keeping a foot inside Perfect's scrimmage line of dexterity and guitar heroism. (My friends, I think when the next album's press kit arrives, I'm going to win my own petty game with that last sentence.) It also recalls last year's fine Halo Benders release, The Rebels Not In, the album Martsch recorded with Beat Happening's Calvin Johnson and former Spinanes and current Built to Spill drummer Scott Plouf. And that's not a bad thing at all.
Seriously, Keep It Like a Secret has already been spun at Club Jason five times within the past 24 hours. That's not a frequent occurrence-- not unless it really, and truly is, love. Doug Martsch just knows how to tickle me in all of the happy places, and he accomplishes that on the merits of the opening number alone. "The Plan" is a brisk, weaving anthem complete with a solo that would make Thurston Moore green with envy. "Center of the Universe," the second cut and first single, conjures up some XTC and a little bit of Barnacle Pete's finer sea shanties. And what have we here? It's the downright pretty "Carry the Zero," which merges Cocteau Twins- esque guitars and melody with equal sigh and much more articulate lyrics, none of which I'm going to quote to you. "Sidewalk" is classic indie rock in sound, classic rock in execution-- something I've been waiting a long time to hear.
Speaking of classic rock, "You Were Right" is a tongue- in- check number about spitting back classic rock lyrics ("You were right when you said all we are is dust in the wind/ You were right when you said that we're all just bricks in the wall"), although why he's doing it is a mystery. But it's a fun mystery. You know, like "Mystery" on PBS, only without that meddling Alistair Cooke. Believe me, if there's one man who can spoil a rock and roll party, it's that evil tool of the Mobil Corporation. Luckily, he's passed on, leaving Diana Rigg to run the show, and she's no match for Martsch. Keep It Like a Secret? No, at the risk of hopping on a cliché wagon, I think I'm gonna tell all my friends about Built to Spill. Try and stop me, Diana.
- Vampire Weekend Vampire Weekend
- Radiohead In Rainbows [CD 2]
- Jonny Greenwood There Will Be Blood OST
- The Mars Volta The Bedlam in Goliath
- Radiohead In Rainbows
- Cat Power Jukebox
- The Magnetic Fields Distortion
- Times New Viking Rip It Off
- Hot Chip Made in the Dark
- Beach House Devotion
- British Sea Power Do You Like Rock Music?
- Atlas Sound Let the Blind Lead Those Who Can See But
- Fleet Foxes Sun Giant EP
- Beck Odelay: Deluxe Edition
- Michael Jackson Thriller: 25th Anniversary Edition
- The Simpsons Testify
- Hercules and Love Affair Hercules and Love Affair
- High Places 03/07 – 09/07
- Stephen Malkmus & the Jicks Real Emotional Trash
- Andrew Bird Soldier On EP
- Xiu Xiu Women as Lovers
- Fuck Buttons Street Horrrsing
- El Guincho Alegranza!
- Black Mountain In the Future
- The Mountain Goats Heretic Pride
- Nine Inch Nails Y34RZ3R0R3M1X3D
- Lupe Fiasco The Cool
- The Ruby Suns Sea Lion
- Goldfrapp Seventh Tree
- Los Campesinos! Hold on Now, Youngster...
- Drive-By Truckers Brighter Than Creation's Dark
- The Raveonettes Lust Lust Lust
- Morrissey Greatest Hits
- Neon Neon Stainless Style
- Daft Punk Alive 2007
- Rivers Cuomo Alone: The Home Recordings of Rivers Cuomo
- Why? Alopecia
- Burial Untrue
- The Honeydrips Here Comes the Future
- Jason Collett Here's to Being Here
Measured over the past 3 months (Last update: 3/25/2008)


Related Reviews & Features
