Recordreviews-header
Portishead: PNYC: Roseland NYC Live Portishead 
PNYC: Roseland NYC Live
[Go Beat/London; 1998]
Rating: 7.6
Buy it from Insound
Download it from Emusic
Digg this article
Add to del.icio.us
"They're dark, they're spooky, they're emotional. Ladies and gentlemen of New York City... presenting Portishead!!" In a perfect world, that's how this live record would kick off. Of course, that's not the band's style. What I'm saying is: they're not KISS. Rather, we hear a few seconds of the 20+ piece orchestra tuning their instruments before the eerie whistle of "Humming" sets in, orchestra right on its tail. Two minutes later, Geoff Barrow's trademark slow-motion hip-hop groove bursts in, followed by Beth Gibbons' emotive, whispery vocals.

Dramatic? There's no doubt about it. This is a band that clearly takes themselves, their music, and their performances very seriously. And naturally, they went for the full effect on July 24, 1997 at New York City's Roseland Ballroom. Pitched as a "one-night only special live engagement", the show sold out almost immediately. The band brought their orchestra, they brought their horn section, they brought their drama, and PNYC documents the performance beautifully.

The album sees Portishead elegantly blow through eleven songs culled from their 1994 debut, Dummy, and last year's self-titled release with decidedly awesome results. The songs from Portishead are relatively straightforward as they were performed purely as an introduction to the album which wasn't to be released for another two months at the time of this concert. The songs pulled from Dummy, on the other hand, are executed beautifully, most notably "Sour Times", which starts off gently and climaxes with Gibbons practically screaming the lyrics, her vocals altered electronically.

I've been searching endlessly for a bootleg of this show, and now I can finally quit looking. I got it on CD, baby! And I didn't spend any $20, either. Get it while the gettin's good.

-Ryan Schreiber, November 01, 1998

Horizontal-dotbar-fw